Tampa, FLA – Spring training is in full swing, and as the Yankees prepare for the upcoming season, a flurry of updates and observations are emerging from their Tampa camp. From injury reports and roster battles to early impressions of key players, there’s a lot to unpack. Here’s a rundown of some notable developments from Yankees camp.
Lineup Issues
Primarily, the offensive output from either Cabrera or Peraza over the long term is unlikely to be sufficient for the demands of the third base position. This could have a detrimental ripple effect on the overall Yankees lineup, especially considering the uncertainty surrounding the future contributions of players like Jasson Dominguez, Austin Wells, and Anthony Volpe.
Additionally, the Yankees ideally see Cabrera in a utility role, similar to how he was utilized for most of the 2024 season. His speed, base running prowess, and defensive capabilities make him a valuable asset late in games, where he can help solidify the infield and maximize the chances of making crucial plays. The Yankees recognize the importance of defensive depth and are keen to leverage Cabrera’s skillset in this regard.
The platoon scenario at third base also raises questions about the team’s long-term strategy at the position. While Peraza and Cabrera may offer short-term solutions, the Yankees will need to consider whether they have a viable long-term option at third base within their current roster or if they will need to explore external options through trades or free agency.
As per Joel Sherman’s report, the Yankees are actively searching for a right-handed batter to fill a corner outfield position or third base. This move is driven by the team’s recognition of a significant imbalance in their lineup due to a lack of right-handed hitters.
The Yankees’ current everyday lineup features only three right-handed batters: Aaron Judge, Paul Goldschmidt, and Anthony Volpe. This is contrasted by two switch-hitters, Oswaldo Cabrera and Jasson Dominguez, and four left-handed hitters: Cody Bellinger, Giancarlo Stanton, Jazz Chisholm Jr. , and Ben Rice. The recent injury to Stanton has further highlighted this disparity.
The Yankees have high hopes for prospect Ben Rice, who has impressed during spring training. Rice is being considered as a potential designated hitter until Stanton returns. The team has also discussed the possibility of acquiring free agents like J.D. Martinez or Anthony Rizzo (who is a lefty), although neither option seems imminent. The organization also does not see players like Alex Verdugo or Nolan Arenado as viable options to fill the void.
The Yankees’ pursuit of a right-handed bat underscores their commitment to addressing the imbalance in their lineup. By adding a right-handed hitter, the team aims to create a more balanced and potent offense. This move could also provide valuable protection for the team’s left-handed hitters, making it more difficult for opposing pitchers to exploit matchups.
Acquiring a right-handed bat could significantly impact the Yankees’ offensive production. A balanced lineup would make the team less predictable and more difficult to defend against. It could also lead to increased run production and improved overall performance. The Yankees’ active pursuit of a right-handed hitter suggests that they are willing to make the necessary moves to improve their lineup and contend for a championship.
The Starting Rotation
The unfortunate injury to Luis Gil, which will likely keep him out for the first half of the year, has left a void in the Yankees’ starting rotation. While many fans and analysts are quick to assume that Marcus Stroman will automatically fill the fifth spot, I believe that the competition is far from settled.
As I expressed on my recent podcast, the decision of who earns a spot in the rotation should not be based solely on salary. While Stroman’s $18.5 million contract is substantial, it shouldn’t guarantee him a starting role. The Yankees need to prioritize winning, and that means choosing the pitcher who gives them the best chance to succeed in each game.
Pitchers like Will Warren and Carlos Carrasco have shown promise and could potentially outperform Stroman. Warren, with his electric fastball and developing secondary pitches, has the potential to be a dominant force in the rotation.
Of course, Stroman’s experience and track record cannot be ignored. He’s a proven veteran who has pitched in big games and knows how to handle the pressures of playing in New York. However, his recent performance has been inconsistent. The Yankees need to weigh all of these factors carefully before making a decision. They need to consider each pitcher’s strengths and weaknesses, their potential for growth, and their ability to contribute to the team’s success. Ultimately, the fifth spot in the rotation should go to the pitcher who earns it, regardless of salary or reputation.
Spring training will be crucial in determining who ultimately claims the final spot in the rotation. The Yankees will have the opportunity to evaluate each pitcher’s performance in game situations and see how they stack up against major league hitters. It’s a competition that will be closely watched by fans and analysts alike, and the outcome could have a significant impact on the Yankees’ chances of success in the upcoming season.
As the Florida sun beats down and the Grapefruit League games are played, the Yankees’ spring training narrative is rapidly taking shape. While these notes offer a glimpse into the team’s preparations, the true test lies ahead when the regular season commences. The coming weeks will be crucial in solidifying roster decisions, addressing lingering concerns, and building the chemistry necessary for a championship run. With a blend of seasoned veterans and promising young talent, the Yankees are poised to make a statement, and the observations gleaned from camp will undoubtedly play a pivotal role in shaping their path to October.
